ATC and Online Flying

IVAO vs VATSIM: Which Online ATC Network Should You Join?

IVAO vs VATSIM compared: coverage, controller training, pilot software, joining and events, plus a simple way to test both networks before choosing one.

On this page
  1. What the two networks have in common
  2. Key differences
  3. Which network should you choose?
  4. How to test both before committing
  5. Can you use both?
  6. What about PilotEdge?

For most new pilots without a regional preference, VATSIM is the safer default: it generally has more pilots and controllers online worldwide, so you are more likely to find ATC when you fly. IVAO is the better pick if its division in your region is more active at the times you fly, if your friends or virtual airline use it, or if you prefer its all-in-one software. Both are free, and nothing stops you trying both.

What the two networks have in common

  • Free to join and use, run by volunteers.
  • Human controllers staffing airports and airspace using real-world-style procedures.
  • Shared traffic: you see other members’ aircraft, and they see you.
  • PC only: both need a pilot client running alongside your simulator, so console editions of Microsoft Flight Simulator cannot connect.
  • IFR and VFR welcome, from airliners to light aircraft and helicopters.
  • Training, ratings and events organised largely through regional divisions.

IVAO was founded in 1998 and VATSIM in 2001, so both have long histories and established communities.

Key differences

VATSIM IVAO
Overall activity Usually more simultaneous pilots and controllers worldwide Smaller globally; can be busy or busier in some regions
Pilot software vPilot (MSFS/P3D), xPilot (X-Plane), swift Altitude
Other software Third-party tools such as VATSpy and community maps In-house suite, including the Aurora ATC client and Webeye map
Controller entry Training and exams required before controlling New controllers can start at some positions sooner, with limits
Before first flight New member orientation required Registration process; check current requirements
Ratings Optional pilot ratings via training organizations Its own separate rating system

Size and coverage

The most important factor is not total membership but who is online where and when you fly. Registered-member numbers include inactive accounts and say little about coverage on a Tuesday evening in your region. VATSIM tends to have more activity in many major airline markets, but some IVAO divisions have very active local communities.

Controller training

On VATSIM, controllers must complete training and pass exams before staffing positions. Some pilots feel this gives more consistent service. IVAO allows newer controllers to start at some positions sooner, which means more positions may be staffed in some places, though experience levels can vary. Both networks have many excellent, patient controllers.

Software

IVAO develops its own software suite, so pilot client, controller client and live map come from one source. VATSIM relies on a set of approved clients built by community developers: vPilot for Microsoft Flight Simulator, xPilot for X-Plane, and swift, which supports several simulators. Setup quality matters more than brand here; whichever client you use, take time with audio and model matching. Our guide on connecting MSFS to VATSIM with vPilot shows what that involves on VATSIM.

Joining process and ratings

VATSIM asks new members to complete a short orientation before connecting as a pilot. Its optional pilot ratings are explained in VATSIM pilot ratings explained. IVAO has its own rating structure and training. Ratings and exams do not transfer between the networks.

Community and events

Both networks run regular events, from regional fly-ins to large worldwide events, and IVAO is known for structured tours. The character of each network depends heavily on your local division: its language, its training, and how welcoming its controllers are to newcomers.

Which network should you choose?

Choose VATSIM if:

  • You have no strong regional preference and want the best general chance of finding ATC.
  • You fly long distances across several regions.
  • Your friends, virtual airline or training group already fly there.

Choose IVAO if:

  • Its live map regularly shows better coverage at your airports and flying times.
  • Your local IVAO division offers training, events or support in your language.
  • You prefer its integrated software after trying it.

How to test both before committing

  1. Write down when and where you usually fly, including the hours in UTC.
  2. Check both networks’ live maps at those times on several different days. One big event can distort the picture.
  3. Confirm client support for your exact simulator and version.
  4. Look at the local division websites for training, procedures and events.
  5. Listen before you fly. Both networks let you connect as an observer or sit at a gate and listen. Hear how controllers sound and how busy frequencies get.
  6. Fly a short, quiet flight on the network that looks best. Most bad first sessions come from setup problems or very busy airspace, not the network itself.

Can you use both?

Yes. You can hold an account on each network and choose per flight. Do not connect the same simulator session to both at once; it creates duplicate traffic and can break both networks’ rules. Read each network’s rules separately, as procedures accepted on one may be handled differently on the other.

What about PilotEdge?

PilotEdge is a paid subscription service with human controllers, focused on North America and staffed on a schedule. Some simmers use it for structured, training-style flying alongside or instead of the free networks. If cost is a deciding factor, our article on whether VATSIM is free explains what you do and do not pay for.

Whichever network you join, the same radio skills apply; see VATSIM radio phraseology for beginners. For the bigger picture, including AI ATC options, read our overview of ATC in Microsoft Flight Simulator.

The complete guide to atc and online flying

ATC in Microsoft Flight Simulator: Default AI vs Real Controllers
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →