The short answer
There’s no official “crappiest plane”, but one name comes up again and again: the Cantilever Aero Company Christmas Bullet, a First World War-era fighter. It’s often called the worst aircraft ever built because its prototypes broke up in the air. Other common nominees include the Blackburn Botha, an underpowered British reconnaissance and torpedo bomber, and the Messerschmitt Me 163 Komet, a rocket fighter whose fuel was so dangerous it could be as much of a threat to its own pilots as to the enemy.
Below, we look at what makes a plane genuinely bad, some famous examples, and which awkward aircraft you can try yourself in a flight simulator.
What makes a plane “crappy”?
It helps to separate a few ideas:
- Badly designed: the aircraft didn’t do what it was meant to do, or had structural, stability or engine problems that couldn’t be fixed.
- Dangerous for its crew: it was capable on paper but had a poor safety record in service.
- Hard to fly: demanding but effective in the right hands. That’s not the same as bad.
- Just old or basic: a 1940s trainer isn’t crappy for lacking a modern autopilot.
The planes that earn the “worst ever” label usually fall into the first two groups.
Famous contenders from aviation history
Christmas Bullet (1919). Designed with a thin, flexible wing and no external bracing, which was unusual for the time. Accounts of its testing describe the wings failing in flight. It’s frequently listed as the worst aircraft ever built.
Blackburn Botha (late 1930s). A British twin-engine aircraft meant for reconnaissance and torpedo bombing. It’s widely described as underpowered and poor in its intended role, and it was quickly moved to training and secondary duties.
Brewster F2A Buffalo (1930s/40s). An early US Navy monoplane fighter. Heavier export versions fared poorly against Japanese fighters early in the Pacific war, although Finnish pilots famously had much better results with lighter variants. That’s a good example of how the same aircraft can be judged very differently depending on how it was used.
Messerschmitt Me 163 Komet (1944). A rocket-powered interceptor with startling speed but only a few minutes of powered flight. It had to glide back to land, and its highly volatile fuel was a serious hazard.
Mignet HM.14 Flying Flea (1930s). A tiny homebuilt aircraft that became hugely popular with amateur builders. A series of fatal accidents was traced to an aerodynamic flaw that could prevent recovery from a dive, and the design was later modified.
Hard to fly vs badly designed
Some aircraft have scary reputations but aren’t “bad”:
- Lockheed U-2: often called one of the hardest aircraft to fly because of its narrow speed margins at very high altitude and its tricky landings. It’s still a highly successful aircraft.
- Gee Bee R-series racers (1930s): tiny, fast racers with huge engines and short fuselages, notorious for being unforgiving. They set records and won races, though not without accidents.
Fly the awkward ones yourself in MSFS
One advantage of a flight simulator is that you can try notoriously difficult or primitive aircraft safely. Depending on your version and edition, Microsoft Flight Simulator includes:
- Wright Flyer: extremely sensitive and hard to control. It’s a good lesson in why early aviation was so dangerous.
- Curtiss JN-4 “Jenny”: slow and underpowered by modern standards, but charming.
- Granville Gee Bee R2/Z (MSFS 2024, top edition): try to keep one straight on takeoff and you’ll understand its reputation.
- Hughes H-4 “Spruce Goose”: the real one flew only once, briefly. In the sim you can take it much further.
The freeware scene adds deliberately silly aircraft too, such as the fictional “Scrapyard Monster” bush plane. See our free MSFS aircraft guide. For more historical aircraft, browse our WWII warbird add-ons.
Why bad planes make good sim flights
Flying a difficult or primitive aircraft teaches you things a modern trainer hides: rudder coordination, energy management and respect for stalls. It’s also a fun break from programming an FMC. If you’d like to compare with a well-behaved modern aircraft afterwards, try the Cessna 172 in MSFS. The contrast is part of the fun.
For the full range of aircraft you can fly, see our flight sim aircraft list and add-ons guide.