The short answer
Both Cessna 172 versions in Microsoft Flight Simulator fly the same way. The difference is how you read and control the aircraft. The steam gauge 172 has the classic six analogue flight instruments (“six-pack”) and separate radios and GPS. It forces you to build a proper instrument scan. The G1000 172 puts everything on two large glass screens, which makes navigation and situational awareness easier but adds menus and buttons to learn.
If you’re training for real, fly whichever panel your flight school uses. If you’re just learning in the sim, steam gauges teach the fundamentals and the G1000 makes cross-country flying more relaxed. Learning both is ideal.
Which 172 versions are in MSFS?
- MSFS 2020 includes a classic 172 Skyhawk with analogue instruments and a 172 with the G1000. Floats and skis variants are also available.
- MSFS 2024 lists two 172s across its editions: a 172 Skyhawk in the Standard edition and a 172 SP in the Deluxe edition and up. Which panels each has, and whether a steam-gauge 172 is in your edition, depends on what you own. Some players on the Standard edition have asked where the “basic” 172 went, so check your aircraft selection and variants before you plan a lesson.
Steam gauges: the classic six-pack
The traditional panel has six primary instruments:
- Airspeed indicator
- Attitude indicator
- Altimeter
- Turn coordinator
- Heading indicator
- Vertical speed indicator
Navigation radios, and usually a Garmin GNS-style GPS, sit in the centre stack. A simple autopilot handles basic modes.
Why fly it:
- You learn a scan: moving your eyes between instruments in a pattern, which is a core instrument-flying skill.
- Heading indicators drift and need realigning with the compass, just like in older real aircraft.
- Everything has one job, so it’s easy to understand.
Drawbacks: it’s harder to keep track of position on a cross-country without the big moving map, and there’s more mental work in instrument conditions.
G1000: the glass cockpit
The Garmin G1000 replaces the six-pack with:
- a PFD (primary flight display) showing attitude, airspeed and altitude tapes, heading and navigation;
- an MFD (multi-function display) with a moving map, engine information, flight plan and more;
- an integrated autopilot with more modes, such as altitude hold, vertical speed, navigation tracking and approach coupling.
In MSFS, the G1000 was substantially upgraded by Working Title as the G1000 NXi. It behaves much more like the real unit than the original launch version.
Why fly it:
- Better awareness: the moving map, terrain and traffic make cross-countries easier.
- Approaches are easier to fly with integrated GPS procedures and autopilot coupling.
- Many modern training aircraft use glass cockpits, so the skills are relevant.
Drawbacks: there are lots of menus, soft keys and knobs, and you can end up looking at screens rather than outside.
Side-by-side comparison
| Steam gauge 172 | G1000 172 | |
|---|---|---|
| Instruments | Six analogue instruments | Two glass displays |
| Learning curve | Simple to understand, harder to master | Easy to fly, more to learn in menus |
| Navigation | Radios plus separate GPS | Integrated GPS and moving map |
| Autopilot | Basic modes | More modes, coupled approaches |
| Scan skill | Teaches a classic instrument scan | Teaches a glass-cockpit scan |
| Best for | Fundamentals, older-aircraft feel | Cross-countries, IFR practice, modern training |
Which should you learn on?
- You’re a student pilot: match your flight school’s aircraft. That’s the most useful thing the sim can do for you. Our article on whether real pilots use Microsoft Flight Simulator covers how pilots use the sim to support training.
- You’re learning just for fun: start with steam gauges for a few hours to understand what each instrument does, then try the G1000.
- You want to fly IFR in the sim: the G1000 makes approaches and holds easier to manage while you learn the procedures.
Practice exercises for each
Steam gauges:
- Fly straight and level for five minutes holding altitude within 100 feet.
- Make standard-rate turns to specific headings using the turn coordinator and a stopwatch.
- Navigate to a nearby VOR using only the radios.
- Practise “partial panel” by covering the attitude indicator and flying on the remaining instruments.
G1000:
- Enter a simple direct-to and then a full flight plan.
- Fly a GPS approach with the autopilot, then fly one by hand.
- Practise holding patterns with the autopilot in NAV mode.
- Fly a “failed screen” scenario where you use the backup or reversionary display.
Upgrades and hardware
- GPS mods: add-ons such as the PMS50 GTN 750 and TDS GTNXi 750 can replace the default GPS in some aircraft. Check compatibility first.
- Freeware 172 variants: community 172 versions with different avionics fits are available. See our free MSFS aircraft guide.
- Hardware G1000 panels: replica G1000 bezels and displays from companies such as SimGauges work with G1000-equipped MSFS aircraft on PC.
- A yoke and rudder pedals make the 172 feel much closer to the real thing.
When you’re ready to step up from the 172, try a light twin such as the Cessna 310, or a fast single like the TBM in our business aircraft guide.