The Honeycomb Alpha and the Logitech G Pro Flight Yoke (originally sold under the Saitek name) are two of the most popular desktop yokes for flight simulation. They are aimed at the same simmer, someone flying light aircraft or Boeing-style airliners, but they take different approaches. The Logitech is a long-running, bundled package with a throttle quadrant. The Alpha is a sturdier-feeling yoke with a built-in general aviation switch panel, but no throttle.
This comparison is based on published specifications and widely reported owner experiences. Prices change often, so check current pricing when you compare.
The Quick Answer
- Choose the Logitech if you want the lowest-cost route to a yoke and throttle in one box, or you already own Logitech panels that match its look.
- Choose the Honeycomb Alpha if you care most about build quality and feel, like having physical light, master and magneto switches, and are happy to buy a throttle separately.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Honeycomb Alpha | Logitech G Pro Flight Yoke | |
|---|---|---|
| Included throttle | No | Yes, a three-lever quadrant |
| Built-in switches | GA switch panel: master, avionics, lights, magneto key | Buttons and switches on the yoke and base |
| Extras | Magneto/starter key switch | Small clock/timer display, built-in USB hub |
| Construction | Generally regarded as sturdier | Mostly plastic, metal shaft |
| Mounting | Desk clamp | Desk clamp |
| Xbox | An Xbox-compatible version has been offered | PC focused, check current listings |
| Typical buyer | Wants feel and GA realism | Wants a complete low-cost bundle |
What’s in the Box
Logitech G Pro Flight Yoke: a yoke, a separate three-lever throttle quadrant with interchangeable knobs, and clamps. The quadrant plugs into the yoke, which connects to the PC.
Honeycomb Alpha: the yoke with its base, which has a row of switches along the front, plus the clamp. There is no throttle, so you need to use a joystick throttle, buy Honeycomb’s Bravo throttle quadrant or choose another unit.
Build Quality and Feel
Owners generally describe the Alpha as feeling more solid, with a heavier base and smoother, more confident movement. The Logitech yoke is lighter and mostly plastic, and its feel is often described as acceptable but less refined.
Both yokes have limited roll travel compared with a real aircraft, which is normal for desktop yokes. Both use a sliding shaft for pitch. How smooth the pitch movement feels, especially around center, is one of the most discussed differences.
Buttons, Switches and Extras
The Alpha’s standout feature is its switch panel: master battery and alternator, avionics, and light switches (beacon, landing, taxi, navigation and strobe), plus a rotary magneto and starter key. For general aviation flying, this lets you run through much of a startup and shutdown by touch, for example in the Cessna 172.
The Logitech yoke has a small built-in display that can show time or act as a timer, a mode switch to multiply its button functions, and a built-in USB hub on the back so you can plug other devices into it.
Throttle Considerations
This is the biggest practical difference. With the Logitech, the bundled three-lever quadrant covers throttle, propeller and mixture for a single-engine piston aircraft, or the throttles for a twin.
With the Alpha, you’ll need a throttle. Many owners pair it with the Honeycomb Bravo, which adds airliner and GA levers, an autopilot panel, gear lever and trim wheel. Others use a Logitech quadrant or an airliner-specific unit. Our throttle quadrant guide covers the options.
Compatibility and Software
Both work with Microsoft Flight Simulator, X-Plane and Prepar3D on Windows as standard USB game controllers, and MSFS includes presets for both. For other simulators you may need to map controls manually. If you fly on Xbox, check for the specific Xbox-compatible version of whichever yoke you choose; our comparison of MSFS on Xbox vs PC explains why.
Once connected, it is worth tuning response in the sim. See our guide to sensitivity curves and dead zones in MSFS.
Common Owner Complaints
These come up often in owner reviews and forum discussions. Experiences vary between units and hardware revisions.
Logitech G Pro Flight Yoke
- A “sticky” feel around the center in pitch, sometimes called stiction, which makes small corrections harder. Some owners lubricate the shaft or use a modification kit.
- Mostly plastic construction.
- Reports of axis noise or the need to tune dead zones.
Honeycomb Alpha
- Fairly strong centering springs and a noticeable feel when passing through center, which some like and others don’t.
- A higher price, before you even add a throttle.
- Clamp fit on very thick or unusually shaped desks.
Total Cost of a Complete Setup
When comparing prices, compare complete setups:
- Logitech: yoke plus included throttle, then add rudder pedals.
- Alpha: yoke, plus a throttle quadrant, then add rudder pedals.
The Alpha route almost always costs noticeably more in total. Whether the better feel and switch panel justify that depends on how much you fly and what you value.
Which Should You Buy?
- Tight budget, want a complete GA setup quickly: the Logitech yoke and its bundled quadrant.
- Mostly light aircraft, want physical switches: the Honeycomb Alpha, plus a throttle.
- Mostly airliners: either works, but consider the airliner throttle you’ll pair with it, and look at Boeing-style yokes if you only fly Boeing.
- On Xbox and want everything in one box: also consider the Turtle Beach VelocityOne Flight.
Still deciding between a yoke and a stick at all? Read the best flight simulator controls for PC.